American Cheese

Stretchy shreds of creamy Italian-style cheese peppered with black truffle for added decadence.

Mild, soft mozzarella with an oval shape and porcelain-like smoothness, made fresh to order

A piquant American blue cheese produced by hand in Iowa since 1941.

Mild and soft-texturedmozzarella hand-spun into an elegant braid shape, great by itself or with accompaniments

A delicious extra mature cheddar cheese from California.

Fresh smoked mozzarella made from scratch in an Italian market, smoked to enhance its natural flavor

A flavorful robust smoked version of the world-famous Gouda.

With a name meaning "milk's flower," this cow's milk mozzarella has a spongy texture and fresh, creamy taste

Specially ordered for the utmost freshness, this soft mozzarella pouch oozes with rich creamy goodness

An ultra-fresh mozzarella casing conceals truffle-infused cream that gushes out when you slice in half

Made in Miami the Italian way, this cow's milk cheese is lusciously creamy and soft with salty notes.

Knot-shaped, rindless mozzarella with spongy, semi-soft texture and mild flavor, delivered fresh to your door

This six time award winner Prairie Breeze aged white cheddar is crumbly yet creamy with a savory finish you’ll love.

This cheese combines the creamy richness of Queso Botanero with the zesty allure of cilantro and jalapeno peppers.

A testament to the art of Mexican cheese-making and the vibrant flavors of Oaxacan cuisine, you’ll love the unique texture of this mild cheese.

Explore the unique qualities of this gourmet addition to Plymouth’s exceptional lineup of cheeses.

Inspired by the alpine cheeses of Switzerland, Pleasant Ridge offers a rich and salty complexity and a long, fruity finish.

A testament to innovation, Red Rock is a blend of orange cheddar and blue cheese, offering a flavorful experience for those seeking something beyond the ordinary.

Hand ladled and ash ripened, goat cheese doesn’t get much better than Sofia!

Offering a soft, bloomy rind and an appetizing profile, Butterbloom is marked by its rich, sweet notes of corn and papaya.

American craftsmanship meets French tradition in this Camembert style cheese from Minnesota.

Foxglove, with its bloomy rind and velvety interior, promises a luxurious eating experience.

This California blue cheese is renowned for its creamy texture and complex flavor profile.

Herbaceous and floral, with distinct notes of mushroom, you’ll love this truffle-infused soft-ripened cheese!

This Brie-style cheese offers a luxurious dining experience with notes of fresh milk and mushrooms.

Hand crafted and cellar cured this Dunbarton marries the sophisticated flavor of a fine English Cheddar with the zing of blue cheese!

This rich Gouda-style cheese offers deep caramel notes, perfectly balanced by savory highlights of flavor.

Mild with a slightly tangy finish, this specialty cheese is as versatile as it is delicious!