Skip to main content

American Cheese

American cheesemaking has made huge headway in the past few decades, offering local dairy cheeses that are so darn delicious they even stand up to the time-honored classics of Europe. The mixture of old and new, the marriage of the cheesemaking secrets of European immigrants with that enviable American spirit for innovation has produced the very best expression of American cheese.

At Gourmet Food Store you can buy a wide selection of top quality American cheese online, including delicious chevres from Vermont Creamery and Cypress Grove, innovative cheddars from California-based Fiscalini, and our exclusive Italian-style mozzarellas and burratas made fresh to order by Mamma's Cheese in Miami. Plenty of choices of cheer-inducing cheeses made right here within our own shores!
Name
Milk Type
Texture
Type
Origin
Shape
Price
Availability
29 - 56 of 111 products
Previous  1 2 3 4  Next
29 - 56 of 111 products
Previous  1 2 3 4  Next
Widmer's Aged Brick Cheese Spread
Widmer's Aged Brick Cheese Spread
from United States by Widmer's Cheese Cellars

Enjoy a smear of Brick cheese on all your favorite foods with this cheese spread from Widmer’s!

Apricity - Soft Ripened Cheese
Apricity - Soft Ripened Cheese
from United States by Alemar Cheese Company

Indulge in the rich complexities of this soft ripened cheese from Alemar Cheese Company.

Piper's Pyramide Goat Cheese
Piper's Pyramide Goat Cheese
from United States by Capriole

This stunning goat’s cheese offers a delicious smoky taste and a striking look, highlighted by its streak of red paprika running through its core.

Trillium
Trillium
from United States by Tulip Tree Creamery

Inspired by lush wheels of Brie, Trillium is a triple-cream bloomy rind cheese offering a spreadable texture and a rich and mild taste.

Sage and Herbs Cheddar
Sage and Herbs Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

An aromatic medley of herbs adds an inspired layer of flavor to Plymouth’s delicious cheddar cheese.

Capriole O'Banon | Chestnut Leaf Wrapped Cheese
O'Banon - Chestnut Leaf Wrapped Goat Cheese
from United States by Capriole

This chestnut leaf wrapped cheese offers a uniquely delicious flavor profile and striking visual appeal.

Julianna Herbed Goat Cheese
Julianna Herbed Goat Cheese
from United States by Capriole

This tangy, herb-infused goat’s milk cheese is a must-have addition to your next charcuterie board or cheese tray.

Cheddar - Aged 3-6 months
Cheddar - Aged 3-6 months
from United States by Hook's Cheese Company

Shabby Shoe - Chabichou Style Cheese
Shabby Shoe - Chabichou Style Cheese
from United States by Blakesville Creamery

An homage to the French Chabichou, this American take on the classic offers a bright profile with notes of sweet citrus flavors, a creamy texture, and a clean finish.

St. Germain
St. Germain
from United States by Blakesville Creamery

This cooked and pressed curd goat cheese with a natural rind is a testament to the artistry of cheesemaking!

Plymouth Original Cheddar
Plymouth Original Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Whether enjoyed on its own or incorporated into culinary creations, this cheese offers a delicious taste of American history.

Lake Effect
Lake Effect
from United States by Blakesville Creamery

A soft-ripened goat cheese with a bloomy rind, Lake Effect is known for its rich, buttery flavor and earthy undertones.

Queso Fresco
Queso Fresco
from United States by Don Froylan

With its creamy texture, mild flavor, and culinary versatility, Queso Fresco elevates a wide range of dishes.

West West Blue
West West Blue
from United States by Parish Hill Creamery

This raw cow’s milk cheese offers a dense, creamy interior and earthy, almost spicy notes of flavor.

Hot Pepper Cheddar
Hot Pepper Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Jalapeno and Habanero peppers add delicious heat to Plymouth’s classic cheddar cheese.

Goat Milk Gouda
Goat Milk Gouda
from United States by Central Coast Creamery

Central Coast Creamery takes this classic to new heights by infusing it with the distinct qualities of goat milk.

After Glow
After Glow
from United States by Blakesville Creamery

This washed-rind lactic cheese promises to delight with its unique and vibrant flavors.

East Meadow Raw Cow Milk Cheese
East Meadow Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Mild and approachable, this all-purpose cheddar goes with just about everything.

Corner Stone - Raw Cow Milk Cheese
Corner Stone - Raw Cow Milk Cheese
from United States by Parish Hill Creamery

A new American classic, Corner Stone is a collaboration between three farms to explore the power of terroir.

Fresh Chevre - Fresh Goat Cheese
Fresh Chevre - Fresh Goat Cheese
from United States by Blakesville Creamery

Big Woods Blue
Big Woods Blue
from United States by Shepherd's Way Farms

Butterkase - Sheep Milk Cheese
Butterkase - Sheep Milk Cheese
from United States by Hook's Cheese Company

American Cheese - Sliced
American Cheese - Sliced
from United States by New School

Sunny Ridge - Beer Washed Goat Cheese
Sunny Ridge - Beer Washed Goat Cheese
from United States by Blakesville Creamery

Humble - Raw Milk Cheese
Humble - Raw Milk Cheese
from United States by Parish Hill Creamery

Cheddar - Extra Sharp, Aged 2 Years
Cheddar - Extra Sharp, Aged 2 Years
from United States by Shelburne Farms

TomaTruffle
TomaTruffle
from United States by Point Reyes

Fromage Blanc - Fresh, Spreadable Cheese
Fromage Blanc - Fresh, Spreadable Cheese
from United States by Briar Rose Creamery

29 - 56 of 111 products
Previous  1 2 3 4  Next

American Cheese Questions And Answers

visit our family of brands
Steaks And Game
For steak and meat lovers.
Gourmet Food World
The chef's ingredient marketplace.