Skip to main content

Cheddar Cheese

Although cheddar cheese has its origins in Cheddar, England (yes, it's an actual place!), this beloved cheese has become an American favorite. From sharp to mild, yellow to white, our gourmet cheddar cheese for sale is versatile, flavorful, and a welcome addition to cheese plates, sandwiches and many dishes.
1 - 24 of 24 products
1 - 24 of 24 products
Fiscalini 18 Month Farmstead Cheddar
Fiscalini 18 Month Farmstead Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini Farm

A delicious extra mature cheddar cheese from California.

5(3 reviews)
Quebec Vintage Cheddar, 6-7 Years
Quebec Vintage Cheddar, 6-7 Years
from Canada by Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar

A vintage Cheddar with bold flavors and a unique production process.

5(3 reviews)
Super Sharp Vintage Cheddar Cheese - Aged Over 3 Years
Super Sharp Vintage Cheddar Cheese - Aged Over 3 Years
from Canada by Old Quebec

A super sharp Canadian cheddar with wonderful caramel notes and a butter, crumbly flavor that's never cloying.

Red Rock - Blue Cheddar Cheese
Red Rock - Blue Cheddar Cheese
from United States by Roelli Cheese Haus

A testament to innovation, Red Rock is a blend of orange cheddar and blue cheese, offering a flavorful experience for those seeking something beyond the ordinary.

Prairie Breeze Cheddar- Precut
Prairie Breeze Cheddar- Precut
from United States by Milton Creamery

This six time award winner Prairie Breeze aged white cheddar is crumbly yet creamy with a savory finish you’ll love.

Black Truffle Cheddar
Black Truffle Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Explore the unique qualities of this gourmet addition to Plymouth’s exceptional lineup of cheeses.

Montgomery's Farmhouse Cheddar
Montgomery's Farmhouse Cheddar
from United Kingdom by Neal's Yard Dairy

Bursting with bold umami flavor, this savory cheddar is firm with a crumbly texture and a finish that lingers on the palate.

East Meadow Raw Cow Milk Cheese
East Meadow Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Mild and approachable, this all-purpose cheddar goes with just about everything.

Sage and Herbs Cheddar
Sage and Herbs Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

An aromatic medley of herbs adds an inspired layer of flavor to Plymouth’s delicious cheddar cheese.

Smoked Cheddar
Smoked Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Cold-smoked, this Vermont cheddar is creamy yet complex, highlighted by meaty notes of flavor.

Hunter Cheddar Cheese
Hunter Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

This cheddar’s depth of flavor and complexity make it a standout in Plymouth's diverse cheese portfolio.

Plymouth Original Cheddar
Plymouth Original Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Whether enjoyed on its own or incorporated into culinary creations, this cheese offers a delicious taste of American history.

Hot Pepper Cheddar
Hot Pepper Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

Jalapeno and Habanero peppers add delicious heat to Plymouth’s classic cheddar cheese.

San Joaquin Gold
San Joaquin Gold
from United States by Fiscalini

A firm cheddar-like cheese with mild, sweet flavor and nutty aroma, great for snacking, grating and melting.

5(4 reviews)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Fiscalini Purple Moon - Wine Soaked Cheddar
Purple Moon - Wine Soaked Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini

A delightful purple-rinded cheddar that's been soaked in a Californian Cabernet for a unique, fruity finish

5(1 review)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Monterey Jack, Dry - Aged 10 Months
Monterey Jack - Aged 10 Months
from United States by Vella Cheese

A classic American cheese, dry-aged 10 months for a firm, straw-hued paste and sweet nutty flavor.

5(1 review)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Fiscalini Hopscotch Cheddar - Scotch Ale Beer Cheddar
Hopscotch Cheddar - Scotch Ale Beer Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini

Soaked in beer, this malty, hop-spiked cheddar is great for casual night snacking, dips, burgers and more.

4(1 review)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Ubriaco del Piave
Ubriaco del Piave
from Italy by Veneto

An incredible cheddar from Italy, soaked in wine, aged in grape leaves.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Fiscalini Smoked Cheddar
Smoked Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini

A caramel-hued cheddar smoked over local apple, cherry and hickory wood chips for a rustic, woodsy flavor.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Grafton Clothbound Cheddar
Clothbound Cheddar
from United States by Grafton

A cheddar-like cheese from the Auverge region, with a mildly sharp taste and smooth texture.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Dunbarton Blue Cheddar
Dunbarton Blue Cheddar
from United States by Roelli Cheese Haus

Hand crafted and cellar cured this Dunbarton marries the sophisticated flavor of a fine English Cheddar with the zing of blue cheese!

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Sambal Cheddar
Sambal Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

This cheese offers everything you love about classic cheddar but with a spicy twist thanks to the addition of chili-based Sambal.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Garlic and Peppercorn Cheddar
Garlic and Peppercorn Cheddar
from United States by Plymouth Artisan Cheeses

This marbled cheddar offers a striking look and a complex flavor perfect for elegant presentations.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
American Cheese
American Cheese
from United States by New School

This gourmet American cheese offers a high-quality taste of nostalgia.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
1 - 24 of 24 products

Cheddar cheese is a smooth, semi-hard cow's milk cheese with a rich, tangy flavor. As delicious as it is versatile, this iconic ingredient is perfect for melting, grating, or enjoying on its own.

More About Cheddar Cheese

In a world of countless cheeses, one stands out with its distinctive flavor, rich history, and universal appeal: Cheddar! Legend has it that this cheese was born out of necessity, as early English farmers needed a way to preserve surplus milk. Little did they know that their creation would revolutionize the cheese-making industry.

Pairing Flavors and Serving

What sets Cheddar apart from other cheeses is its incredible versatility. From mild to sharp, it caters to a wide range of tastes. Its texture can vary too, from smooth and creamy to crumbly and aged. It's this adaptability that has made this ingredient a staple in households around the globe and a cherished element in countless recipes.

A perfect balance of savory and nutty notes, add a creamy touch to pasta dishes, enhance simple sandwiches, or add a flavorful punch to casseroles. To enjoy it at its best, be sure to serve Cheddar at room temperature; this allows the full flavor of this tasty cheese to be savored.

Pricing Cheddar Cheese

When it comes to the world of cheese, pricing can be as complex as the flavors and textures themselves. Cheddar cheese, with its wide range of varieties and aging processes, offers a spectrum of prices to match.

Costs are influenced by a combination of factors, including the quality of milk, the aging process, region of origin, brands, and market dynamics. While premium cheeses may demand a higher price due to their exceptional quality and craftsmanship, there are also more affordable types available that offer a delightful eating experience. Ultimately, the world of cheese holds something for everyone, regardless of cost.

Ordering Cheddar Cheese from Gourmet Food Store

At Gourmet Food Store, we have an excellent selection of cheeses to suit every palate and predilection. From savory smoked cheddar to truffle-infused varieties, enjoy a range of flavorful options. Whether you’re looking for a whole wheel or portions priced by the pound, you’ll find it on our easy-to-navigate online storefront. Low fat, high fat, wine-soaked, and more, our staggering array of delicious options offers something for everyone to buy.

Shop our selection along with other gourmet ingredients and enjoy convenient next-day shipping, excellent customer service, competitive pricing, and regular sales when you order through our website!

Cheddar Cheese Questions And Answers

Q:What’s the Difference Between Normal Cheese and Cheddar Cheese?
A:Cheddar distinguishes itself with its distinct flavors and textures, resulting from a cheesemaking process known as cheddaring. Cheddaring requires formed curds to be cut into small pieces and stacked in layers. The stacked curds are then turned and flipped periodically to expel whey and create the characteristic crumbly and granular texture of Cheddar.
Q:Why is Cheddar Cheese Yellow or White?
A:Despite its color, both white and yellow varieties are the same. The only difference is the inclusion or exclusion of the natural coloring agent annatto.
Q:Is Cheddar Cheese Healthy?
A:An integral part of a balanced diet, providing protein, calcium, and other health benefits, cheese is high in calories, sodium, and fat, so moderation is key.
Q:How to Make Cheddar Cheese?
A:Start by heating milk (this is general cow’s milk but some artisanal varieties sometimes call for goat milk). Incorporate a starter culture to form curds. Drain the whey and press it into solid wheels, then age it to develop its distinct flavors and textures. The longer you age it, the sharper it becomes.
Q:Where is Cheddar Cheese From?
A:The history books trace the origin of Cheddar cheese to the village of Cheddar in Somerset, England. Its name pays homage to the place where it was first produced, a region known for its traditional cheesemaking heritage.
visit our family of brands
Steaks And Game
For steak and meat lovers.
Gourmet Food World
The chef's ingredient marketplace.